top of page

When the Tool Is Gone

3 days ago
9 min read

Every school is deciding which AI tools to adopt. Almost none are deciding what happens when those tools end.


An article from the Build series: AI, Part Three


This fall I went looking for one file and found six.


Over the past few years, BLAC has moved through more AI tools than I can easily count. I started with Gemini and Copilot, moved my writing to ChatGPT, tried Marblism for social posts, and now do most of my work in Claude. My meetings went from Zoom recordings and a transcription app to a Plaud recorder. Each switch made the work better. None of them came with a plan for what I was leaving behind.


Every one of those tools still holds something: drafts, prompts, meeting transcripts, and the reply sweeps that keep my outreach on track. The volume was not the real surprise. The copies were. The same roster and the same rules lived in several files that pointed at each other, so no single file was the source of truth. If one of those tools had disappeared that week, I could not have told you which version of my own work would survive it.


Not every tool protects what you give it, either. In June 2025, people using Meta's AI app found that conversations they believed were private, about health, legal disputes, and work, were appearing in a public feed, because sharing took fewer steps than many users understood (Arntz, 2025). That August, a proposed class action accused a popular meeting transcription service of recording conversations without every participant's consent and using them to train its AI (NPR, 2025).


I am a small firm, and those files are mine. Now picture the same thing inside a school, where the files are about children.


In Automate the Mundane to Protect the Human, I argued that technology should return time to the relationships only people can build. In Skill Before Shortcut, I argued that policy must come before adoption. This piece is about the other end of a tool's life, the part almost no one plans for: the day it is gone. By “tool” I mean any system that holds your community’s information: an AI assistant, a student information system, a donor database, a recording app. AI makes the question urgent, but the question is older than AI.


None of this is an argument against new tools. I am pro-AI, and every switch I described made my work better. But I am pro-AI with limits: boundaries on what a tool may touch, and a plan for how it ends before it begins. The point is not to switch less. It is to switch well, and a switch is the best moment a school will ever get to start clean.


The Pattern Is Everywhere


In March 2024, Los Angeles Unified launched "Ed," an AI assistant for students, under a five-year contract worth about $6 million. By June, the company behind it had furloughed most of its staff, and the district shut Ed down. EdSurge asked what every family would ask: where did the student data go? The contract said the district owned it (EdSurge, 2024), but a contract is only as strong as the company still standing to honor it. Months later, attackers reached one of the most widely used student information systems in the country, and districts reported stolen records reaching back to the 2009 to 2010 school year, including students long since graduated (Page, 2025). Data outlives the people it describes, and often the reason it was collected.


Closer to Home


Independent schools live this every few years. The student information system is Blackbaud, Veracross, or SchoolAdmin: fill in the blank, and remember that SchoolAdmin itself became part of Finalsite in 2021 (Finalsite, 2021). Schools that once sent families through the School and Student Service for Financial Aid (SSS), the NAIS service many independent schools have relied on for decades, now send them to Clarity, a newer financial aid application. Admissions moves from Ravenna, which began in 2012 with Seattle's independent schools, to HubSpot or the reverse (Ravenna Solutions, n.d.). Advancement moves decades of giving history out of Raiser's Edge and into Veracross or a lighter donor platform such as Bloomerang or DonorPerfect. The whole campus moves from PCs to Macs, or from Outlook to Gmail.


Each move is sold as an upgrade, and most of them are.


Every migration carries a question no one puts on the agenda: what did we leave behind?

The notes field that never mapped to the new system. The inquiry history from before the cutover. The donor history, and the notes that explained each relationship. The financial aid files, tax returns included, from families who never enrolled. The inbox of the admissions director who left the summer before the switch. Some of it is lost. Some of it still sits with the old vendor, long after the contract ended.


That second risk is not hypothetical. In 2020, a hacker reached customer databases hosted by a major school software provider and removed large amounts of unencrypted personal data. When the Federal Trade Commission settled with the company in 2024, it found that the company had held onto data "far longer than was necessary," including data about former customers, and ordered it to delete what it no longer needed and to set a schedule for deleting the rest (Federal Trade Commission, 2024).


The hardest tools to shut down are the ones no one approved: the free account a teacher opened for one assignment, or the personal subscription that holds an admissions director's notes on families. NAIS found that 84 percent of teachers already use AI for at least one administrative task (Stringer & Foley, 2026). When the person who opened that account leaves, those records leave with them, and the school never knew they existed.



Why Schools Are Different


The method that follows works anywhere a tool holds people's information. Schools, though, hold something different. They hold children's records, a family's finances, and its health. A financial aid file is a window into a family's life: its income, its debts, sometimes a divorce or a loss. A health file holds what a family shared so the school could care for their child. Together, they hold a family's trust.


What the Rules Already Say


The guidance points in one direction. The Department of Education's privacy office tells schools to require vendors to destroy student data "upon termination of the school official relationship (e.g., when the contract ends)" (Privacy Technical Assistance Center, 2019). The Federal Trade Commission now requires companies serving children to keep a written data retention policy with a time limit (Federal Trade Commission, 2025).


Schools are teaching this. The NAIS report AI in Independent Schools found that the share of teachers covering privacy and data security in classroom conversations about AI doubled in a year, from 20 percent to 40 percent. The same report found that a quarter of division heads say their school has no AI policy for faculty and staff (Stringer & Foley, 2026).


We are teaching students to protect their data faster than we are protecting it ourselves.

This fall, an esteemed classmate of mine from William and Mary, Dr. Devan Ray Donaldson, gave a presentation at the University of Washington. It was a luxury to sit in that room and watch someone I have known since college set the pace for his field. He put one question on a slide that I have not stopped thinking about: what happens to the data when the AI system is gone? (Donaldson, 2026).


What I Finally Understood


I had been treating the end of a tool as a cleanup task, something to handle when the time came.


What I finally understood is that the ending of a tool is decided on the day it is bought, whether anyone decides it or not. If the contract is silent and no one inside the school owns the question, the ending gets decided by the vendor, by whoever buys the vendor, or by whoever breaks in.


Every tool you adopt will end. Decide what happens to the data on the day you sign, not the day you leave.

So I changed how I leave a tool. When a trial ends or a subscription lapses, I do four things, in order. First, I turn off the tool's access to my accounts and files. Second, I pull down everything it holds: the prompts, the transcripts, the "brains" I built inside it. Third, I delete what is left on the old platform by hand. Only then do I bring what I kept into the new service. It is the surest way I know to make sure nothing of mine stays behind. Even then, I read the old vendor's deletion policy, because some keep backups for a period after you press delete, and a request to close the account is often the final step.



What Is Really at Stake


The real cost is not a fine or a headline. It is trust.


A family will forgive a tool that stops working. What a family struggles to forgive is learning that their child's words, records, or questions lived on after the tool was gone, and that no one at the school could say where. Trust is how a family decides whether it belongs, the question at the heart of Directions, Not Stages.


A school that cannot answer for its data is asking families to belong on faith.

The Method: Plan the Ending First


Three steps, each small enough to start this term.


1. Four questions for heads and boards. Adapted, with credit, from the four competencies in Dr. Donaldson's DECODE research at Indiana University (DECODE, n.d.), and asked for every tool before it is approved:


  • Keep: What data will this tool hold, and which of it is worth keeping? (appraisal and selection)

  • Document: Will we know where that data came from, who touched it, and how it was used? (documentation and provenance)

  • Protect: When the tool ends, how will what we keep stay private and secure? (preservation and access)

  • Own: Who, by name, is accountable for this data from purchase to exit? (accountability and governance)


The board asks these questions once a year, and leadership brings the answers. That keeps the board in governance and the work with the people who run the school.


2. A one-page data exit plan for every tool. Written the day you sign:


  • What the tool holds, and where, including backups

  • When it ends, item by item: keep, transfer, or delete

  • What the contract requires of the vendor: return or destroy, the method, a signed certification, and a deadline

  • Who signs off, and when the plan was last tested


Test it once on a low-risk tool before you ever need it for a high-risk one. The plan belongs in the contract, which means the business office has to be in the room on the day you sign, not just the technology team.


The Data Exit Plan, a one-page fill-in template for deciding what happens to a tool's data when it ends
Click the image to expand it.


3. Name a data steward. One person, by name, with a direct line to the head of school, who keeps the inventory of tools, holds every data exit plan, reviews them each quarter, and signs off when a tool ends. It can be part of an existing role. It can never be "everyone."


Start with the tool you are most likely to drop next. Write its one page this week.

The fillable version is one page per tool. Get it free with the button below.


If this sounds familiar


If your school can name every tool it uses but not what happens to the data when each one ends, that ending is already being decided for you. I would welcome a conversation about writing your first data exit plan and naming the person who owns it.



References


Arntz, P. (2025, June 13). Your Meta AI chats might be public, and it's not a bug. Malwarebytes. https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2025/06/your-meta-ai-chats-might-be-public-and-its-not-a-bug


DECODE. (n.d.). DECODE [Research project website]. Indiana University. https://decode-ai.org


Donaldson, D. R. (2026, October 16). Trustworthy information: Building bridges across archives, biomedical informatics, and artificial intelligence [Research symposium presentation]. Information School Research Symposium, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States. https://ischool.uw.edu/events/calendar.aspx?id=1546


EdSurge. (2024, July 15). An education chatbot company collapsed. Where did the student data go? EdSurge. https://www.edsurge.com/news/2024-07-15-an-education-chatbot-company-collapsed-where-did-the-student-data-go


Federal Trade Commission. (2024, February 1). FTC order will require Blackbaud to delete unnecessary data, boost safeguards to settle charges its lax security practices led to data breach [Press release]. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/02/ftc-order-will-require-blackbaud-delete-unnecessary-data-boost-safeguards-settle-charges-its-lax


Federal Trade Commission. (2025). Children's Online Privacy Protection Rule [Final rule, effective June 23, 2025; compliance required by April 22, 2026]. Federal Register.


Finalsite. (2021, March 10). Education technology leader Finalsite acquires SchoolAdmin, an innovative digital enrollment solutions company [Press release]. Business Wire. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210310005702/en


Lee, J. E. (2026, October 12). Automate the mundane to protect the human. Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/automate-the-mundane-to-protect-the-human


Lee, J. E. (2026, October 29). Skill before shortcut. Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/skill-before-shortcut


Lee, J. E. (2026, November 2). Directions, not stages: A compass for boards and associations. Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/directions-not-stages-a-compass-for-boards-and-associations


NPR. (2025, August 15). Class-action suit claims Otter AI secretly records private work conversations. https://www.npr.org/2025/08/15/g-s1-83087/otter-ai-transcription-class-action-lawsuit


Page, C. (2025, January 15). PowerSchool data breach victims say hackers stole "all" historical student and teacher data. TechCrunch. https://techcrunch.com/2025/01/15/powerschool-data-breach-victims-say-hackers-stole-all-historical-student-and-teacher-data/


Privacy Technical Assistance Center. (2019). Best practices for data destruction (PTAC-IB-5). U.S. Department of Education. https://studentprivacy.ed.gov/sites/default/files/resource_document/file/Best%20Practices%20for%20Data%20Destruction%20(2019-3-26).pdf


Ravenna Solutions. (n.d.). About Ravenna. https://www.ravennasolutions.com/about/


Stringer, G., & Foley, B. (2026). AI in independent schools: Policy formed, practice forming [Research report]. National Association of Independent Schools.


The four competencies are credited to Dr. Devan Ray Donaldson and the DECODE project at Indiana University; BLAC adapts them for schools and does not repackage them. Nothing in this article is legal advice; read your own contracts with counsel.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page