top of page

Directions, Not Stages: A Compass for Boards and Associations

Nov 2
11 min read

Boards are asked to govern enrollment, retention, and reputation. Beneath all three sit four questions that most boardrooms never ask out loud.


An article on the BLAC Framework


I once sat in a board meeting where a consultant presented a study of the organization's untapped giving capacity. The figure ran into the hundreds of millions of dollars. It was a remarkable number. What it could not tell the board was which of those donors felt connected to the mission, or who, if anyone, had ever opened that door for them. Capacity measures wealth. Giving follows relationship.


Boards are accustomed to measuring what has already happened. Applications and yield. Attrition and re-enrollment. Faculty turnover. Annual giving. Each figure arrives in the board book, the packet trustees read before every meeting, as a result, after the decisions that produced it have long since been made.


I have seen this from every seat at the table. I have presented to boards, served on a board to which a head of school reported, and reported to a head of school myself. I have led admissions at three independent schools, and I spent five years supporting international students after enrollment, where an institution's promises meet its daily practice. Since 2021, the Our Faces, Our Voices archive has gathered more than forty recorded interviews and 180 published alumni accounts across more than ninety institutions.


Alongside it sit the structured ninety-day and exit conversations I have conducted throughout my career, the moments when a person is new enough to see an institution clearly or leaving and free to say what they saw.


That body of work is qualitative research, and I treat it as such. Each account is read and coded against the same framework, so that individual stories become patterns an institution can act on. Across all of it, I have asked hundreds of structured questions, the same questions in the same order, so that one person's answer can be read beside another's. Boards are fluent in quantitative evidence; they are less practiced at treating lived experience as evidence. Yet lived experience is often the only place an institution can see what its numbers cannot: why a family left, why a student stayed, who quietly held the door.


Work of this kind is never finished. What follows is not a final answer for boards but an inventory of considerations, one that grows more accurate each time someone new is heard. What all of it shows is that the results in the board book trace back to the same four questions. The BLAC Compass gives them a form a board can use.


The Compass



Access: Who opened the door?

Belonging: Where do I fit here?

Navigation: How does this place really work?

Opportunity: What's possible now?


Each direction points to something an institution is responsible for. Access is about reach: who the institution reaches, and who it relies on to reach them. Belonging is about relationships: whether people are known, not just enrolled. Navigation is about structures: whether the way things work responds to the people inside them. Opportunity is about momentum: what becomes possible after a person arrives.


Access: Who opened the door?


Access is usually reported as an admission outcome. In practice, it is a network of relationships, and most institutions do not know who is in theirs. Nearly every account in the archive names a person who made entry possible: a coach, a teacher, a community program, a family friend who understood the process.


Those relationships carry consequences well beyond admission. The Gallup-Purdue Index, drawing on more than 30,000 college graduates, found that graduates who had a professor who cared about them, a professor who made learning exciting, and a mentor who encouraged their aspirations had more than double the odds of being engaged at work. Only 14% reported all three (Gallup & Purdue University, 2014).


For a board, the implication is strategic:


An enrollment pipeline that depends on chance relationships is a pipeline the institution does not control.

Who Helped You Get Here? and The BLAC Network are both efforts to make those relationships visible, and therefore repeatable.


The board's question: Do we know which relationships produced our last three entering classes, and which of those pathways would survive the departure of one person?


Belonging: Where do I fit here?


Admission confirms eligibility. It does not confirm membership.


NAIS has documented the gap inside its own schools. In the Independent School Health Check, roughly half of high school students agreed that they belonged at their school, and among Black students the figure was 39.6% (Wilson, 2018). More recent NAIS analysis describes belonging as something students infer from cues: whose success is visible, who participates, and who shapes the community (Brooks, 2026).


Companies meet the same question under a different name. BetterUp's study of 1,789 employees associated a strong sense of belonging with a 56% increase in job performance, a 50% reduction in turnover risk, and a 75% reduction in sick days (BetterUp, 2019).


A school calls it belonging; a company calls it retention. On a balance sheet, they are the same line.

Every student who leaves in the second year and every faculty member who leaves in the third represents an investment the institution has already made and will now make again, a cost I set out in The Cost of Not Listening.


The board's question: Do we measure belonging with the same rigor and frequency that we measure retention, and do we review them side by side?


Navigation: How does this place really work?


Every institution operates under two sets of rules: those it publishes and those its members actually follow. Fluency in the second set is unevenly distributed before anyone arrives.


The Association of Boarding Schools and Canadian Accredited Independent Schools surveyed more than 11,000 students and alumni in 2024. Boarding students were 50% more likely than their non-boarding peers to learn one-on-one with teachers and 28% more likely to report a voice and choice in their education; boarding alumni were 19% more likely to report that school prepared them to manage their time in college (The Association of Boarding Schools & Canadian Accredited Independent Schools, n.d.). That is a difference in practice, not ability: years of early rehearsal in talking with adults and reading how a place works. A boarding school is a living community, something I learned first as a student and later working inside one. In a living community, the unwritten rules are taught at dinner, in the residence hall, and on the walk back from practice, every day, by people who already know them.


The lesson for any institution, residential or not, is that navigation is learned inside a community, not at orientation. The question is whether the institution designs for that learning or leaves it to chance.


Anthony Abraham Jack found the same pattern at an elite university: lower-income students from well-resourced high schools navigated college with a fluency their similarly situated peers never had the chance to build (Jack, 2019).


Navigation, in other words, is learnable, and therefore teachable. That is the premise of The Shakespeare Exam: an institution that leaves its working rules unwritten will consistently reward those who arrived already knowing them. For a board, unwritten rules are also a risk. They concentrate what the institution knows in a few people and leave newcomers, whether students, faculty, or trustees, to learn by trial and error.


The board's question: Which of our working rules are unwritten, who bears the cost of learning them, and have we asked leadership to tell us?


Opportunity: What's possible now?


Opportunity is where the compass returns to the individual, and where an institution's mission is ultimately tested: what does a person leave able to do that they could not do before?


Like access, the answer runs through people. In 2022, economist Raj Chetty and colleagues at Opportunity Insights published a study in Nature that analyzed 21 billion friendships among 72.2 million Facebook users. They found that economic connectedness, how many friends people from lower-income families have in higher-income circles, is among the strongest predictors of upward mobility identified to date. Their estimate: if children from low-income families grew up in counties as connected as those of the average higher-income child, their adult incomes would rise by about 20% on average (Chetty et al., 2022). The next door is usually opened by a person, and the compass comes full circle.


That makes opportunity a question of capacity. Every hour lost to administrative work is an hour not spent on the introduction, the recommendation, or the conversation that opens that door, the argument of Automate the Mundane to Protect the Human. It is why policy must come before adoption, as I argue in Skill Before Shortcut: technology should return time to the relationships only people can build.


The board's question: Do we know who opens the next door for our graduates and our people, and have we decided, as a matter of policy, what must stay human?



What I Finally Understood


The four pillars of the BLAC Framework were originally drawn as a sequence: Access, then Belonging, then Navigation, then Opportunity. That model was incomplete. What I finally understood is this:


These are not stages to be completed but directions to be checked, and every threshold resets them.

The student who mastered one institution's unwritten rules returns to the question of access at the next. Belonging earned in college must be re-earned in the first role. A seasoned executive who joins a board for the first time is, for a season, a newcomer asking how this place really works.


This matters for governance because institutions are always receiving people at a threshold: new families, new faculty, new hires, new trustees. A board that checks all four directions at each threshold governs the conditions that produce its results, rather than only reviewing the results themselves.


Testing the Promise


A board's most direct tools are the ones it approves: the mission, the vision, and the strategic plan. The mission says whom the institution serves, the vision says who it hopes to become, and the strategic plan, built by the head of school and leadership team under the board's oversight, sets the route between them.


Many boards have adopted, or are about to adopt, a portrait of a graduate: a description of who a student should be when they leave. It is one of the most important documents a board approves, because it is the institution's promise made specific. Families enroll for that person. Faculty teach toward that person. Donors and sponsors give to that person, because people fund what they can see.


A portrait describes a destination. The strategic plan describes the route. Neither shows who reaches the end of it.

The compass is how a board tests the promise. Every trait in a portrait can be checked against the four directions. A school that promises graduates who advocate for themselves must ask who was shown how this place really works (Navigation). A school that promises graduates who lead with empathy must ask whether every student found a place where they fit (Belonging). A school that promises graduates ready for what comes next must ask what became possible, and for whom (Opportunity), and who opened the door in the first place (Access).


The same test applies when a strategic plan is renewed. A priority that is strong in one direction and silent in the others is not a reason for the board to rewrite the plan; it is a reason to ask leadership for evidence before approving it.


I first learned to build that kind of evidence inside a boarding school, following each class across its four-year arc. Financial aid, grades, college outcomes, gender, and race, read side by side, year over year. The purpose was never to rank students. My hope then, and now, was to see whether the school's promise held for every group of students, and to find exactly where it bent, early enough to do something about it.


Numbers can show where the promise bends. They cannot say why.


The evidence for the why lives in what recent graduates, long-tenured teachers, departing families, and alumni of every decade say the promise looked like from inside. Listening to them in a disciplined, structured way is how a portrait becomes something a board can verify rather than merely hope.


The board's question: Can we show, direction by direction, that our portrait of a graduate holds true for every graduate, and not only for those who arrived already holding the map?


For Associations: The View No Single Institution Has


An association sees something its members cannot: the same pattern recurring across dozens or hundreds of institutions. One school may experience second-year attrition as a local problem. Across a membership, it is a direction on the compass that a region or a sector is consistently missing.


The compass gives associations a common language for that view. Members can locate themselves on the same four questions, compare where their needles point, and learn from peers who have already turned in a direction they have not. It can also organize professional development by direction rather than topic, so a member who says "we are weakest at Navigation" can find the sessions, peers, and resources that address it.


Applying the Compass in the Boardroom


The compass is a governance instrument, and it respects the line between governance and management. The board asks the questions; the head of school or chief executive and their team bring the evidence. One board or committee session is enough to begin:



  1. Begin with what the board already owns: the mission, the vision, and the current or pending strategic plan. Then select one threshold population: incoming families, first-year faculty, new hires, transfer students, or the board's own newest members.

  2. Pose all four questions from that population's perspective, and ask the leadership team to answer with evidence rather than impressions.Evidence can be as simple as a summary of what new families said at ninety days, or why the last ten departing families left. The board asks for the summary and the pattern, not the files or the names; gathering it and acting on it stay with leadership.

  3. Classify each answer: known, assumed, or never asked.

  4. Ask the head of school to propose how the institution will learn more about the weakest direction, and agree on when the board will hear back. The first response should be a structured listening effort, not a new program.

  5. Return to the compass annually, at a different threshold. The weakest direction will move, and that movement is itself useful information.


Board books report results. The compass shows where the results are coming from. It underpins the Institutional Voice work I conduct with schools, and it anchors my session at NAIS Gather in Boston on December 3, Belonging, Educational Navigation, and Institutional Voice.


If this sounds familiar


If your board can answer one of these four questions with evidence and the other three with assumptions, the compass has already identified your priority. I would welcome a conversation with board chairs, heads of school, and association leaders about where to begin.



References


BetterUp. (2019). The value of belonging at work: The business case for investing in workplace inclusion. https://grow.betterup.com/resources/the-value-of-belonging-at-work-the-business-case-for-investing-in-workplace-inclusion


Brooks, P. (2026). NAIS research advisory: Fostering student belonging: Frameworks, challenges, and strategies for inclusive school communities. National Association of Independent Schools. https://www.nais.org/resource-center/resources/research/nais-research-advisory-fostering-student-belonging


Chetty, R., Jackson, M. O., Kuchler, T., Stroebel, J., Hendren, N., Fluegge, R. B., Gong, S., Gonzalez, F., Grondin, A., Jacob, M., Johnston, D., Koenen, M., Laguna-Muggenburg, E., Mudekereza, F., Rutter, T., Thor, N., Townsend, W., Zhang, R., Bailey, M., . . . Wernerfelt, N. (2022). Social capital I: Measurement and associations with economic mobility. Nature, 608(7921), 108-121. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-04996-4


Gallup & Purdue University. (2014). Great jobs, great lives: The 2014 Gallup-Purdue Index report. Gallup. https://news.gallup.com/opinion/gallup/173624/gallup-purdue-reveal-findings-college-graduates.aspx


Jack, A. A. (2019). The privileged poor: How elite colleges are failing disadvantaged students. Harvard University Press.


Lee, J. E. (2026, September 16). Who helped you get here? Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/who-helped-you-get-here


Lee, J. E. (2026, September 26). The cost of not listening. Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/the-cost-of-not-listening


Lee, J. E. (2026, September 28). The Shakespeare exam. Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/the-shakespeare-exam


Lee, J. E. (2026, October 12). Automate the mundane to protect the human. Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/automate-the-mundane-to-protect-the-human


Lee, J. E. (2026, October 29). Skill before shortcut. Bridging Legacies Across Campuses. https://www.bridginglegaciesacrosscampuses.org/post/skill-before-shortcut


The Association of Boarding Schools & Canadian Accredited Independent Schools. (n.d.). School life in focus: The boarding advantage [Survey report; survey conducted March to May 2024 by AH Datalytics]. https://boardingschools.com/wp-content/uploads/School-Life-in-Focus-The-Boarding-Advantage.pdf


Wilson, D. P. (2018). A sense of belonging can drive up engagement [Excerpt]. In 2018-2019 NAIS trendbook. National Association of Independent Schools. https://www.nais.org/articles/pages/books/trendbook-excerpt-a-sense-of-belonging-can-drive-up-engagement/


The compass graphic is original BLAC work. Alumni figures (more than forty recorded interviews and 180 published accounts across more than ninety institutions, since 2021) come from the Our Faces, Our Voices archive. Boarding school figures are self-reported survey results published by the boarding school associations; they compare boarding and non-boarding students and do not by themselves establish cause.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page